What We Review
Developing a Strong Literary Argument
Crafting a persuasive argument is essential for AP® Lit success. It allows readers to explore a text from a deeper perspective by revealing insight beyond surface-level details. At the core of every literary argument is a clear, assertive statement—often called a claim—that is backed by convincing text evidence. Mastering this skill enables students to write essays that reflect both clarity and critical thinking, two qualities highly valued on the exam.
In the sections that follow, we’ll break down how to construct a strong claim and support it with evidence drawn from texts as varied as modern novels, Shakespearean dramas, and classic poetry.
What is a Claim?
A claim is an overarching statement that an essay sets out to prove. Rather than summarizing the plot, a strong claim presents a meaningful assertion about the text. This assertion often focuses on a character’s motivation, a central theme, or the effect of a particular literary device on the story’s meaning.
For instance, in short fiction, a claim might spotlight a protagonist’s conflict and explain how it deepens the author’s message. In drama, it could point to a tragic flaw or a pivotal turning point. Regardless of genre, a claim serves the same purpose: it guides readers and explains why the analysis matters.
Example of a Claim
Consider F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby. A claim about this novel could read: “In The Great Gatsby, Gatsby’s pursuit of the American Dream ultimately leads to his downfall.”
This statement clearly identifies a focus for analysis and signals that the essay will examine how Gatsby’s actions and tragic end reflect broader themes of ambition and disillusionment. It also implies that textual evidence will be used to support the argument, particularly moments that show Gatsby’s relentless hope and its consequences.
The Importance of Evidence
After establishing a claim, the next step is to support it with text evidence. This can include direct quotations, paraphrased moments, or summarized scenes that reinforce the argument. Without this layer of support, an argument becomes just an opinion.
Authors often include carefully placed clues—lines of dialogue, symbolic descriptions, or structural choices—that reveal how characters think, how settings influence outcomes, or how themes are developed. Therefore, selecting the right evidence is crucial. It must align precisely with the claim and strengthen the essay’s core idea.
Example of Evidence
Continuing with The Great Gatsby, evidence might include one telling piece of dialogue: “Can’t repeat the past? Why of course you can!”
This short line captures Gatsby’s unwavering hope.
Step by step, consider how to identify it as relevant evidence:
- First, identify the context: Gatsby is trying to rekindle a romance that has long passed.
- Next, consider its meaning: It shows his idealistic view that the American Dream includes restoring the past.
- Finally, link it back to the claim: Gatsby’s inability to accept reality contributes to the tragic ending the essay explores.
Developing a Paragraph with a Claim and Evidence
A strong paragraph weaves together a clear claim and relevant evidence. Typically, it starts with a topic sentence that previews the main point. This is followed by the claim itself, the introduction of evidence, thoughtful analysis, and a conclusion that connects back to the original idea.
Here’s a breakdown of the structure:
- Topic Sentence: Introduces the paragraph’s main idea.
- Claim: Makes a specific argument about a character, event, or theme.
- Evidence: Provides a quote, paraphrase, or summary that supports the claim.
- Analysis: Explains how the evidence proves the point and why it matters.
Example of a Complete Paragraph
Gatsby’s misguided optimism reveals how a single-minded pursuit of dreams can be both inspiring and destructive. In The Great Gatsby, Gatsby passionately insists, “Can’t repeat the past? Why of course you can!” While this exclamation seems hopeful, it also highlights his unwillingness to live in reality. By clinging to an unrealistic vision, he disregards present opportunities and endangers meaningful connections. Ultimately, Fitzgerald uses Gatsby’s refusal to accept life’s changes to underscore the broader idea that unrestrained ambition, without logical reasoning, leads to downfall.
This paragraph links the claim—that Gatsby’s dream causes his downfall—to specific evidence, demonstrating how to weave textual moments into a cohesive argument.
Tips for Crafting Strong Claims and Evidence
- Keep Claims Clear and Specific: Vague statements lead to confusion and limit the depth of analysis.
- Choose Relevant and Persuasive Evidence: Look for quotes or references that best illuminate the claim rather than any random detail.
- Use Logical Reasoning: Bridge the gap between the claim and the evidence with explanations that solidify the connection. Without this step, readers may fail to see how facts support the assertion.
Additionally, genre matters. In longer fiction, a writer might rely on key turning points or dialogue. While in poetry, the emphasis often falls on imagery, word choice, and structure. On the other hand, powerful soliloquies or stage directions can provide critical clues in drama. Always consider the specific tools each genre uses to convey meaning.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Some students write claims that are too broad or vague. A statement like “Hamlet is sad” lacks direction and fails to show how that sadness drives the plot or illuminates a theme.
Other common pitfalls include selecting irrelevant evidence or failing to analyze it. Simply inserting a quote isn’t enough. Instead, introduce it with context, interpret its meaning, and link it back to your claim. This approach ensures your writing remains cohesive and persuasive.
Evidence Do’s and Don’ts
| Type of Mistake | Weak Example | Why It’s Weak | Stronger Example | Why It’s Better |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Too Vague or Broad Claim | “Hamlet is sad.” | Lacks insight and doesn’t suggest an argument or theme to explore. | “In Hamlet, the prince’s sorrow over his father’s death reveals his internal struggle with moral action.” | Makes a clear assertion and opens the door for deeper analysis of character motivation and theme. |
| Irrelevant Evidence | “Hamlet says, ‘To be or not to be.’” | Famous quote, but doesn’t clearly connect to the argument without explanation. | “When Hamlet asks, ‘To be or not to be,’ he reveals his paralysis in deciding whether life is worth living.” | Provides context and analysis that ties the quote to a deeper theme of indecision and existential crisis. |
| No Analysis | “Gatsby says, ‘Can’t repeat the past? Why of course you can!’” | Quote is inserted without any commentary or connection to the argument. | “Gatsby’s quote reveals his delusional belief that he can recreate a lost ideal, a flaw that leads to his downfall.” | The analysis explains the meaning of the quote and directly ties it to the claim about Gatsby’s tragic ambition. |
| Overly General Evidence | “The author uses symbolism.” | Too vague; doesn’t identify specific symbols or their relevance. | “The green light at the end of Daisy’s dock symbolizes Gatsby’s unreachable dream and the illusion of the American Dream.” | Offers a specific example and explains how the symbol supports a broader thematic claim. |
Final Tip:
When writing literary analysis, clarity and precision are everything. A strong claim gives your essay direction, and thoughtful evidence proves your point. Always ask yourself: Does this quote support my argument? and Have I explained why it matters? With consistent practice, these habits will turn your writing from average to analytical—and help you succeed on the AP® Lit exam.
Quick Reference Chart
Below is a brief chart of key vocabulary. This can serve as a handy reminder of the building blocks of any strong literary argument.
| Term | Definition |
| Claim | A statement, often debatable, that an essay sets out to prove. |
| Evidence | Specific textual support (quotes, summaries, or paraphrases) used to strengthen an argument. |
| Text Evidence | Direct lines from the text or carefully paraphrased ideas that reinforce the writer’s main point. |
| Logical Reasoning | The explanation of how and why the evidence supports the claim, ensuring coherence and clarity. |
| Assertion | A confident statement that expresses the writer’s standpoint and requires defense with evidence. |
Putting It All Together
When writing about short stories, novels, plays, or poems, always pair a focused claim with well-chosen text evidence. Doing so guides readers through the author’s purpose and highlights key insights. This approach also reveals a student’s confident grasp of AP® Lit tasks. Above all, articulate a clear argument, incorporate meaningful quotes, and offer thoughtful analysis for every piece of supporting material. Such steps fortify any literary essay and arm students with a proven strategy for tackling a range of classic and contemporary works.
Sharpen Your Skills for AP® English Literature and Composition
Are you preparing for the AP® English Literature and Composition test? We’ve got you covered! Try our review articles designed to help you confidently tackle real-world AP® English Literature and Composition problems. You’ll find everything you need to succeed, from quick tips to detailed strategies. Start exploring now!
- AP® English Literature: How to Write a Thesis Statement
- AP® English Literature: Commentary and Reasoning
- AP® English Literature: Textual Evidence
- AP® English Literature: Elements of Composition
Need help preparing for your AP® English Literature and Composition exam?
Albert has hundreds of AP® English Literature and Composition practice questions, free response, and full-length practice tests to try out.
